Mauricio Pochettino’s appointment should reignited optimism among Manchester United fans, with his Premier League pedigree, Tottenham achievements, record of developing young players and admiration for Sir Alex Ferguson offering hope of a fresh start at Old Trafford.
It took 13 years, seven permanent appointments and several near-misses, but Mauricio Pochettino is finally Manchester United’s head coach.
The Argentine has signed a two-and-a-half-year deal and officially starts work on Wednesday, November 18, replacing Michael Carrick, who was sacked after winning just one of United’s first ten Premier League games of the season.
Pochettino is the eighth permanent manager at Old Trafford since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013, following David Moyes, Louis van Gaal, Jose Mourinho, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, Erik ten Hag, Ruben Amorim and Carrick.
He is also the first manager from outside Europe in the club’s history as every man before him, from the Victorian era to the Ferguson dynasty and the turbulent years since, came from Britain or continental Europe.
United have been linked with Pochettino so many times that the appointment can feel overdue. He was a candidate in 2016, the favourite after Mourinho left in 2018, and lost out narrowly to Ten Hag in 2022. Now that he has finally arrived, the mood among supporters is unusually hopeful. Here are five reasons why.
1. How he finished at Chelsea
Mauricio Pochettino’s exit from Chelsea in May 2024 surprised many people, mainly because of how his season ended. After a slow start badly hit by injuries, his young and expensive squad found their form. They lost only one of their last 15 league games and won the final five in a row, rising to sixth and qualifying for Europe.
He left by mutual consent days later, reportedly after disagreements with the owners over transfer policy, not results. For United fans, that late run is what stands out. With a squad still learning to play together, he showed he can build a team that improves as the season goes on. That is exactly what United need now, in 18th place in the table.
2. His love of Sir Alex Ferguson
Pochettino has never hidden his admiration for Ferguson. One comment that went round again after his appointment was his answer when asked which three Premier League managers he would most like to learn from: “Sir Alex Ferguson, Sir Alex Ferguson, Sir Alex Ferguson.”
His respect for Ferguson goes back a long way. The pair famously had lunch in Mayfair in 2016, a meeting Pochettino later called a dream come true. Ferguson, for his part, reportedly saw the Argentine as the best manager in the Premier League at the time.
This week, ahead of his first day, Mauricio Pochettino said Sir Alex Ferguson represents everything he admires in a coach, a manager and a man. For a fanbase that still measures every manager against Ferguson, that matters.
3. What he built at Tottenham
The Argentine’s work at Tottenham Hotspur is still the main reason for his reputation. He arrived in 2014 and turned a side known for falling short into a serious force. Spurs finished in the top three for three seasons in a row. Their second place in 2016-17 was the club’s best league finish in 54 years. In 2019 he led them to their first and only Champions League final.
He did it without huge spending, relying instead on coaching, high-intensity pressing and young players he trusted to grow. Harry Kane, Dele Alli and Eric Dier all developed under him. At a club with United’s history of promoting academy players, his record with young talent may be his strongest selling point.
4. A big step up from Carrick
Maichel Carrick deserves credit. He took over as interim boss after Ruben Amorim was sacked in January, guided United to third place and earned the job permanently. But this season’s collapse showed the limits of his inexperience.
Mauricio Pochettino’s CV is in a different league. Since Tottenham, he has won Ligue 1, the Coupe de France and the Trophée des Champions with Paris Saint-Germain. He then took the United States to the knockout rounds of a home World Cup.
Few managers available today have coached at such a range of clubs and national teams, and few have handled so many star players. United even paid a release clause of around $10 million to free him from his US Soccer contract, which shows how much the club wanted him.
5. The most exciting appointment since Mourinho
The last proven Premier League manager Manchester United appointed was Jose Mourinho, more than ten years ago, in 2016. Since then the club has tried a former player with limited top-flight experience in Solskjaer, an interim promoted after a strong spell in Carrick, and two coaches who had succeeded outside Europe’s top five leagues in Ten Hag at Ajax and Amorim at Sporting. All four fell short.
Pochettino is different. He has managed more than 300 Premier League matches with a win rate of about 51 per cent, and he knows the league’s pressure and pace. He won’t need time to adjust, which matters at a club that cannot afford another settling-in period.
The verdict
Fondness for the past alone won’t save United’s season, and Mauricio Pochettino arrives with a real job on his hands. He has a squad low on confidence, a captain whose future is uncertain and a run of difficult fixtures, starting at Anfield.
But for the first time in years, United have appointed someone whose record, temperament and admiration for the club’s traditions all fit. And now the work begins.
